Hydroelectric power, using the potential energy of rivers, now supplies 17.5% of the world’s electricity (99% in Norway, 57% in Canada, 55% in Switzerland, 40% in Sweden, 7% in the US). Apart from a few countries with an abundance of it, hydro capacity is normally applied to peak-load demand, because it is so readily stopped and started. It is not a major option for the future in the developed countries because most major sites in these countries having the potential for harnessing gravity in this way are either being exploited already or are unavailable for other reasons such as environmental considerations. Growth to 2030 is expected mostly in China and Latin America.
Hydroelectricity is available in many forms, potential energy from high heads of water retained in dams, kinetic energy from current flow in rivers and tidal barrages, and kinetic energy also from the movement of waves on relatively static water masses. Many ingenious ways have been developed for harnessing this energy but most involve directing the water flow through a turbine to generate electricity. Those that don’t usually involve using the movement of the water to drive some other form of hydraulic or pneumatic mechanism to perform the same task.
Like steam turbines, water turbines may depend on the impulse of the working fluid on the turbine blades or the reaction between the working fluid and the blades to turn the turbine shaft which in turn drives the generator. Several different families of turbines have been developed to optimize performance for particular water supply conditions.
Turbine Power Output
In general, the turbine converts the kinetic energy of the working fluid, in this case water, into rotational motion of the turbine shaft.
Swiss mathematician Leonhard Euler showed in 1754 that the torque on the shaft is equal to the change in angular momentum of the water flow as it is deflected by the turbine blades and the power generated is equal to the torque on the shaft multiplied by the rotational speed of the shaft.
Note that this result does not depend on the turbine configuration or what happens inside the turbine. All that matters is the change in the angular momentum of the fluid between the turbine’s input and output.
Hydroelectricity Generation Efficiency
Hydroelectricity generation is by far the most efficient method of large scale electric power generation. See Comparison Chart. Energy flows are concentrated and can be controlled. The conversion process captures kinetic energy and converts it directly into electric energy. There are no inefficient intermediate thermodynamic or chemical processes and no heat losses. The overall efficiency can never be 100%, however since extracting 100% of the flowing water’s kinetic energy means the flow have to stop.
The conversion efficiency of a hydroelectric power plant depends mainly on the type of water turbine employed and can be as high as 95% for large installations. Smaller plants with output powers less than 5 MW may have efficiencies between 80 and 85 %. It is difficult to extract power from low flow rates.
Note: The theoretical Betz conversion efficiency limit of 59.3% which represents the maximum efficiency which can be obtained from a wind turbine, does not apply to hydraulic turbines since there are many variations in turbine designs and more possible controls of the water flows. This means that there are equivalent variations in potential turbine efficiency, many of which can exceed the Betz limit.
Dam Power (Potential Energy)
- Supply Characteristics
A hydroelectric dam installation uses the potential energy of the water retained in the dam to drive a water turbine which in turn drives an electric generator. The available energy depends on the head of the water above the turbine and the volume of water flowing through it. Turbines are usually reaction types whose blades are fully submerged in the water flow. The diagram opposite shows a typical turbine and generator configuration as used in a dam.
The civil works involved in providing hydro-power from a dam will usually be many times the cost of the turbines and the associated electricity generating equipment. Dams provide a large water reservoir from which the flow of water, and hence the power output of the generator, can be controlled. The reservoir also serves as a supply buffer storing excess water during rainy periods and releasing it during dry spells. The build-up of silt behind the dam can cause maintenance problems.
- Available Power
Potential energy per unit volume = ρgh
Where ρ is he density of the water (103 Kg/m3 ), h is the head of water and g is the gravitational constant (10 m/sec2)
The power P from a dam is given by
P = ηρghQ
Where Q is the volume of water flowing per second (the flow rate in m3/second) and η is the efficiency of the turbine.
For water flowing at one cubic metre per second from the head of one metre, the power generated is equivalent to 10 kW assuming an energy conversion efficiency of 100% or just over 9 kW with a turbine efficiency of between 90% and 95%.
Run-of-River Power (Kinetic Energy)
- Supply Characteristics
Run-of-river installations do not depend on flooding large tracts of land to form dams. Instead, the necessary constant water supply may be derived from natural upstream lakes and reservoirs. They are typically used for smaller schemes generating less than 10 MW output power.
Water from a fast flowing river or stream is diverted through a turbine, often a Pelton wheel which drives the electrical generator. The local head of water may be essentially not much more than zero and the turbine is designed to convert the kinetic energy of the flowing water into the rotational energy of the turbine and the generator. The available energy depends on the quantity of water flowing through the turbine and the square of its velocity.
Impulse turbines that are only partially submerged are more commonly employed in fast flowing run-of-river installations while In deeper, slower flowing rivers with a greater head of water, fully submerged Kaplan reaction turbines may be used to extract the energy from the water flow.
Run-of-river projects are much less costly than dams because of the simpler civil works requirements. They are however susceptible to variations in the rainfall or water flow which reduces or even cut off potential power output during periods of drought. To avoid the problems of seasonal river flows, or even daily fluctuations, run-of-river installations may incorporate an additional, limited amount of man-made water storage, referred to as “pondage”, to keep the plant operating during dry periods.
On the other hand, during flood conditions the installation may not be able to accommodate the higher flow rates and water must be diverted around the turbine losing the potential generating capacity of the increased water flow.
Because of these limitations, if the construction of a dam is not possible, run of river installations may also need to incorporate some form of supply backup such as battery storage, emergency generators or even a grid connection. See Capturing Renewable Energy for more details on back-up options.
- Available Power
The maximum power output from a turbine used in a run of river application is equal to the kinetic energy (½mv2) of the water impinging on the blades. Taking the efficiency η of the turbine and its installation into account, the maximum output power Pmax is given by
where v is the velocity of the water flow and Q is the volume of water flowing through the turbine per second.
Q is given by
Q = A v
where A is the swept area of the turbine blades.
This relationship also applies to shrouded turbines used to capture the energy of tidal flows (see below) and is directly analogous to the equation for the theoretical power generated by wind turbines. Note that the power output is proportional to the cube of the velocity of the water.
Thus the power generated by one cubic metre of water flowing at one meter per second through a turbine with 100% efficiency will be 0.5 kW or slightly less taking into account the inefficacies in the system. This is only one-twentieth of the power generated by the same volume flow from the dam above. To generate the same power with the same volume of water from a run of river installation the speed of the water flow should be √20 meters per second (4.5 m/sec).
- Supply Characteristics
Harnessing the power of the tides can be achieved by placing bi-directional turbines in the path of the tidal water flow in bays and river estuaries. To be viable, it needs a large tidal range and involves creating a barrier across the bay or estuary to funnel the water through the turbines as the tide comes in and goes out. Although tidal energy captured in tidal ponds have been used since Roman times to power mills, there are few modern installations. The first plant to utilize tidal energy on a large scale for electricity generation was built at Rance in France in1966. Others followed in Canada and Russia.
Tidal power comes closest to all the intermittent renewable sources being able to provide an unlimited, continuous and predictable power output but unfortunately, there are few suitable sites in the world and environmental constraints have so far prevented their general acceptance.
Shrouded water turbines placed in deep water tidal currents show better potential for exploitation, though the associated civil works are more complicated, and several projects are under development.
Power is available for only six to twelve hours per day depending on the ebb and flow of the tides.
- Available Power
The maximum power output from a shrouded water turbine used in tidal energy applications is equal to the kinetic energy of the water impinging on the blades, similar to the “run of river” calculation above. Taking the efficiency η of the turbine and its installation into account, the maximum output power Pmax is given by
where v is the velocity of the water flow and A is the swept area of the blades.
A turbine one meter in diameter with a water current of one meter per second flowing through it would generate 0.4 kW of electricity assuming 100% efficiency. Similarly, a 3-meter diameter turbine with a water current of 3 meters per second would produce 32 Kw of power.
- Supply Characteristics
The energy available from the ocean’s surface wave motion is almost limited, but it has proved frustratingly difficult to capture. Many ingenious systems have been proposed but, except for very small installations, very few are generating electricity commercially and most have been thwarted by practical problems.
Some of these proposals are outlined below. Most are still in an experimental phase and many are not scalable into high capacity systems.
- Energy Conversion Systems
- Oscillating Float System
One of the simplest and most common solutions is the oscillating float system in which a float is housed inside a cylinder shaped buoy which is open at the bottom and moored to the seabed. Inside the cylinder, the float moves up and down on the surface of the waves as they pass through the buoy.
- Various methods have been employed to turn the motion of the float into electrical energy including:
- Hydraulic systems in which air is compressed in a pneumatic reservoir above the float during its upward movement on the crests of the waves. After the crests have passed, the air expands and forces the float downwards into the following troughs of the waves. A hydraulic system then uses the reciprocating movement of the float to pump water through a water turbine which drives a rotary electrical generator.
- Pneumatic systems in which the air displaced in the cylinder is used to power an air turbine which drives the generator.
- Linear generators to turn the reciprocating motion of the float directly into electrical power.
- Instead of generating the electricity onboard the buoy, some systems pump the hydraulic fluid ashore to power shore based generators.
This system uses large paddles moored to the ocean floor to mimic the swaying motion of sea plants in the presence of ocean waves. The paddles are fixed to special hinged joints at the base which use the swaying motion of the paddles to pump water through a turbine generator.
- Oscillating Snake System
The snake system uses a series of floating cylindrical sections linked by hinged joints. The floating snake is tethered to the sea bed and maintains a position head on into the waves. The wave-induced motion at the hinges is used to pump high-pressure oil through hydraulic motors via smoothing accumulators. The hydraulic motors in turn drive electrical generators to produce the electrical power.
- Oscillating Water Column
Water columns are formed within large concrete structures built on the shoreline or on rafts. The structure is open at both the top and the bottom. The lower end is submerged in the sea and an air turbine fills the aperture at the top. The rising and falling of the water column inside the structure moves the air column above it driving the air through the turbine generator. The turbine has movable vanes that rotate to maintain unidirectional rotation when the movement of the air column reverses.
- Pressure Transducer System
The hydraulic pump system uses a submerged gas-filled tank with rigid sides and base and a flexible, bellows-like, top. The gas in the tank compresses and expands in response to pressure changes from the waves passing overhead causing the top to rise and fall. A lever attached to the centre of the top drives pistons, which pump pressurized water ashore for driving hydraulic generators.
- Wave Capture Systems
Wave capture systems use a narrowing ramp to funnel waves into an elevated reservoir. Waves entering the funnel over a wide front are concentrated into a narrowing channel which causes the amplitude of the wave to increase. The increased wave height coupled with the momentum of the water is sufficient to raise a quantity of water up a ramp and into a reservoir situated above the sea level. Water from the reservoir can then be released through a hydroelectric turbine located below the reservoir to generate electricity.
- Overtopping Wave Systems
These are floating systems similar to the land based system described above. They focus waves onto a tapered ramp which causes their amplitude to increase. The crests of the waves overtop the ramp and spill into a low dam. Water from the low dam then flows through hydroelectric turbines back into the sea beneath the floating structure.
- Lever Systems
Various lever based energy capture systems have been developed. Long levers may be mounted on steel piles or on floating platforms. Large floats or buoys are attached to the extremities of the levers which move up and down with the waves. Movement of the lever arms forces fluid into a central hydraulic accumulator and through to a generator turbine. Alternatively, high-pressure water can be pumped ashore to power shore-based generators.
Formidable technical challenges are involved in designing practical systems for capturing wave energy.
- Variability of the sea conditions
Sea conditions are notoriously variable and the system must be able to cope with a wide range of wave amplitudes and frequencies as well as changes in the directions of currents.
- Matching the generating equipment the wave characteristics
Mechanisms are required to convert the power of the irregular oscillating mechanical forces induced by the waves into electrical power synchronized with the grid. This could involve some expensive power electronics. Typical rotating machines used for power generation operate at a synchronous speed of 1200 r.p.m. (20 revolutions per second) whereas the frequency of waves driving the generator is likely to be between 5 and 10 seconds per cycle. A mechanical gearing system is needed to match this 200:1 ratio in operating speeds, possibly combined with a special purpose, slow speed generators, incorporating a large number of pole pairs. One way around all of these problems is to use hydraulic accumulators either in situ or onshore to smooth out the energy delivery to the generator.
- Equipment construction
For reasonable sized systems, very high mechanical forces will be involved in converting the wave energy into mechanical energy for driving the electrical generator.
- Housing and mooring the equipment
Substantial housings must be provided to protect the generating equipment from the harsh environment. Holding the installation in place is also particularly difficult in deep water.
- Energy transmission
Low loss armoured and insulated cables or high pressure pipes must be developed for delivering the electrical or hydraulic energy back to shore.
- Resistance to storm damage
Storm damage is a major threat. The frequency of occurrence of waves of any particular amplitude follows a Rayleigh distribution similar to that which applies to wind speeds. Though the frequency of serious storms may be rather small, a wave ten times the average amplitude may be expected once every 50 years. From the power calculation below, the wave power is proportional to the square of the wave amplitude. This means that the installation must be designed to withstand forces one hundred times greater than the normal working level. This adds considerably to the costs.
The wave power per unit length of the wave front PL is given by (Twiddel & Weir. Renewable Energy Resources) as
Where ρ is he density of the water (103 Kg/m3 ), a is the wave amplitude (half of the wave height), g is the gravitational constant (10 m/sec2), λ is the wave length of the oscillation and T the period of the wave.
Thus for a wave with amplitude 1.5 metres, length 100 meters and period 5 seconds, the power per meter of wavefront will be 75 kW.